Rare Freestanding Retail Opportunity in Montauk, New York.
Highly Visible Montauk Core Location – This 4,300sf free standing retail building has been a beloved fixture in Downtown Montauk, occupied by the same department store for decades. Overlooking Carl Fisher Plaza, Montauk’s bustling Downtown Core, the property enjoys premier visibility as traffic flows naturally toward its striking A-frame design and large, sun-lit facade. The space also benefits from stunning evening sunlight, further enhancing the usability of the space.
Flexible Central Business (CB) Zoning – Zoned for CB – Central Business, the building is ideal for a range of uses, including gallery, bank, personal services, and retail. Its clear-span A-frame structure and expansive front wall of windows provide an open, adaptable interior perfect for showcasing products or creating an inviting retail environment.
Globally Recognized Beach Town – Montauk’s Downtown is the epitome of a relaxed beach town with upscale appeal, drawing high-spending locals and visitors. Known for its vibrant community events, Carl Fisher Plaza regularly hosts weekly farmers markets, live music, and holiday celebrations, bringing waves of pedestrian traffic and creating a lively atmosphere. This prime location allows tenants to capture Montauk’s unique blend of laid-back coastal charm and high-energy commerce.
Rare Lease Opportunity – With its historic presence, excellent sun exposure, and position at the center of Montauk’s thriving downtown, this building is ideally suited for businesses looking to establish a prominent brand footprint in the Hamptons. The property’s flexible zoning, spacious layout, and seasonal crowd draw make it a valuable opportunity for retail or service establishments eager to capture Montauk’s high-demand market.
Surrounding Neighbors:
Streetfood on the Green, Tauk at Trail’s End, FedEx, Homeport, Becker Home Center, Landshark, Naturally Good, Alimentari Beach Montauk, M&T Bank, SoulCycle, Montauk Brewing Co.
Hal Zwick
Compass
